Record - Sarah K. Cheema and Anooradha Iyer Siddiqi - On Inheritance

On Inheritance

Sarah K. Cheema and Anooradha Iyer Siddiqi

Arc_record_ASSC_01
Minnette de Silva, saris with dumbara mat mal gaha (tree of life) motif, Kandy, ca. 1947–68. Courtesy of Helga de Silva Blow Perera. Photo by author, Helga’s Folly, Kandy, 2014. See also Anooradha Iyer Siddiqi, “Crafting the Archive: Minnette De Silva, Architecture, and History,” The Journal of Architecture 22, no. 8 (2017), 1323.
Record
November 2026

Sarah K. Cheema: Your book project, Ecologies of the Past, examines the intertwined intellectual worlds of Sri Lankan art historian Anil de Silva-Vigier (1909–96) and architect Minnette de Silva (1918–98), and how their engagement with questions of questions of ecology, craft, monuments, villages, modern architecture, and critical heritage practice were brought into relation with wider pan-Asian and Afro-Asian debates in architecture, art, and culture at the time. It seems to begin from a question that is at once historical, methodological, and ethical: How do certain lives, practices, intellectual worlds, and material environments come to be held across time? How has the work of these two figures changed the way you think about history, inheritance, and historiography?

Anooradha Iyer Siddiqi: Anil de Silva-Vigier and Minnette de Silva were special and also an unsurprising product of their times. What stands out to me is that they each attempted to do something important: to write a history that creates a constellation of things I believe we need to care about, to record in our historiographies. Anil’s writings attempted to bring works of art to the public, while Minnette de Silva experimented with articulating modernist architecture using Sri Lankan materials and visual languages. But their work—individually and together, published and unpublished, built, designed, and thought—is largely about conveying historically significant environments and histories rooted in experiencing and understanding environments. Their work has made me think deeply about history, historiography, and inheritance—who provides and receives the inheritance of history, how it is held, how there must be one who tells and one who listens, to carry a narrative forward.

Left: Portrait of Anil de Silva, undated. Women’s Education and Research Centre (WERC) library, Colombo. Original photograph unattributed. Photo by Methmini Karyakarawana, 2023. Right: Portrait of Minnette de Silva, undated. Women’s Education and Research Centre (WERC) library, Colombo. Original photograph unattributed. Photo by Methmini Karyakarawana, 2023.

SKC: That formulation is very powerful, especially because it shifts history away from narration alone and towards attention, relation, and care. What makes their lives, archives, and intellectual practices such generative sites for rethinking history through architecture, craft, and ecology? 

AIS: Their intellectual careers illuminate a historiographical condition: that there are people who narrate history, others who hold and carry that narration, and still others who receive the narrative without necessarily being its bearers. I want to capture the work of all these people. On the one hand, in the work of hereditary craftspeople such as those the de Silva sisters attended to, there is a direct, relational passing down of history through material forms. On the other, there is what we associate with colonial practices of historiography, where there are documents and somebody appointed to read the documents and be the narrator. What has interested me is the notion that these two intellectuals appointed themselves in this role. I do not mean that they assumed power—even ordinary people become scholars and historians—but they found themselves in such a role as they pursued the things they cared for. In the late-imperial, and, later, postcolonial social and cultural sphere that they occupied, they found themselves doing historical and even historiographical work.

SKC: What do you mean they “found” themselves in such a role?

AIS: They were organizing and interpreting the ways in which history came down to them. They were doing abstract intellectual work, in contrast to the concrete acts of bearing historical knowledge through material transmissions that are associated with the craftspeople they labored alongside and valorized in their work. I am interested in bridging the work of very practical bearers of history, such as craftspeople, with that of historians or historiographers whose occupation is more abstract. The work of the de Silva sisters, however situated, was not always tethered to place, as the work of weavers, woodworkers, or potters is. It had mobility and the capacity to speak across nationalities and borders. 

SKC: I’m struck by how you are framing historiography as something people come to inhabit, rather than a simple relation to evidence.

AIS: Diverse archives have helped me think with the work and intellectual careers of these two protagonists. But I also feel that they are a kind of cipher to help think about how histories are told, and who will hold them in the future. What is more interesting to me than what Anil de Silva-Vigier and Minnette de Silva did was what they attempted to do. Their work was part of an intellectual and material ecology, which, for me, is the lesson. 

SKC: That expanded idea of inhabitation seems to connect closely to the ecological dimension of the book, where architecture and craft are not only objects of study but ways of understanding changing worlds.

AIS: These two intellectuals held a core concern with ecology. And given our own ecological horizon, so much of what they were trying to register, preserve, and also honor, feels critical today. It was central in what they were thinking about. And it is significant in terms of what we have to think about today. We cannot not think about it today. I found myself only really starting to understand their work when I began looking at art and architecture as a form of inhabited ecologies, from ancient times to the present. They were pulling ecologies of the past into the present day, in the ways they were speaking of, writing on, and designing and building ecologies of the past in the present. 

Minnette de Silva, Pieris House, Colombo, undated. Image in Minnette de Silva, The Life and Work of an Asian Woman Architect (Smart Media Productions, 1998), 189. Original photograph unattributed. See also Siddiqi, “Crafting the Archive,” 1319.

SKC: Can you elaborate on this relation to time in their work? 

AIS: There is, of course, a sense of futurity to acts of preservation, but they seemed always to be writing for their own present. And they lived in such a tumultuous present: “the end of empire,” the decolonization and reconstruction of a postcolony through fraught times, and the fragmented ways that happened. They lived through war, and they lived through profound changes in the fields that they were most concerned with—both art history and architecture. Architectural modernism was a pivotal interest for both of them, but also archaeology and its many findings as a “modern” field—archaeological knowledge enabled both India and Sri Lanka to recast their national narratives in the twentieth century.

SKC: The role of inheritance operates across several different scales in your work: the familial, the craft-based, the caste-bound, the national, the institutional, and the global. How do you understand these various forms of inheritance, and what kinds of tensions emerge when knowledge conserved within intergenerational caste-enclosed communities is taken up by national heritage projects, global institutions, or architectural historiography?

AIS: That's the crux of the problem at the heart of the book. These two figures, especially Anil, help to clarify the social and cultural history of UNESCO and the postcolonial problem of “world heritage.” Critical heritage practices defined their work. So, these are figures whose work we should examine in order to study both craft, at a granular level, and national and international heritage, in its expansive aspirations. Writing about their work and practices provides a hidden history of UNESCO at the level of two of its cultural laborers, and in reverse, writing about UNESCO and its projects historically contextualizes a set of situated spatial, material, and intellectual practices.

SKC: How do you see this relating to wider questions of architectural history today?

AIS: Architectural historians need to constantly negotiate between the universal and the particular. I do not think we can focus on only one or the other, either in the discourse of our field or in using the many tools and records available to us, both architectural and art historical. There are many different forms of evidence we can draw from; we know how to work with documents, material culture, visual culture, media, buildings, land. To me, the task is to learn how to move appropriately between them. You noted several scales, from the familial to the national. To me, attentiveness to these many scales is not special; it is simply good architectural history. Think about Swati Chattopadhyay’s recent book, Small Spaces: Recasting the Architecture of Empire (2023). What is important about this book is that its approach is, well, if not ordinary, then not unfamiliar.

SKC: In your project, that movement across scales also seems to become a feminist problem: how to write intellectual lives that have not been given the same disciplinary weight or form.

AIS: This is a feminist history in the end, not necessarily because of the consideration of two women, but because this is a restorative project. I have recently been reading two books. One is by Gottfried Semper, who casts such a shadow over our field.1 In some ways, Semper’s life story is not so different from those of these two sisters. He moved in and out of institutions; he had nervous breakdowns; he had jobs; he did not have jobs; he wrote; he failed to write; he did not complete things; he completed things late. It is interesting to me that this is what towering figures in a field look like. To me, what is similar in both the work of Semper and the de Silva sisters is the attempt. That is what I am trying to record: what they were attempting. I am mentioning Semper, too, because of his core contribution to the South Kensington educational system, which is the educational system that Minnette de Silva was educated in, and that she extends in various ways. To me, this direct genealogical connection is part of the inheritance. 

I have also been reading about Kamaladevi Chattopadhyay.2 She is known best as a freedom fighter in the years leading up to India’s independence, as well as a proponent of village-based systems of craft production. However, she is also a crucial figure for understanding the practice of the de Silva sisters. This is not only because of her personal connections to their family and because her work unlocks a fuller understanding of the ways in which craft production was centered in the postcolonial political economies of South Asia. She is also key to understanding an emergent anticolonial pan-Asian and Afro-Asian imaginary and dialogue, which was forwarded by both Anil de Silva-Vigier and Minnette de Silva. Anil de Silva-Vigier compiled a pan-Asian art and architectural history, while Minnette de Silva became a live conduit for Afro-Asian and tricontinental dialogue, attending conferences and expanding the remit of her research to what is now considered global architectural history. An Afro-Asian dialogue is most often associated with state-based endeavors, in which Chattopadhyay played a critical part. However, she is also a figure behind many ground-level endeavors around crafts. The work of Anil and Minnette de Silva is also part of grassroots efforts. Seeing Semper and Chattopadhyay as part of a discursive and intellectual genealogy that includes Anil and Minnette de Silva illuminates a kind of historiographical care I want to take.

SKC: The research for your book considers intergenerational knowledge, moving between the embodied knowledge of craftspeople, the intellectual genealogy of the de Silva sisters, and your own long relationship to their papers, personal effects, relatives, collaborators, and afterlives. What responsibility does a historian have when writing about forms of knowledge that pass through hands, bodies, families, villages, and intimate memory, rather than only through formal archives?

AIS: That is a very loaded question. I want to be careful about what we mean by responsibility. Do we mean that a historian has responsibility because of some embodied connection to the subject? Or do we need to debunk that? Minnette de Silva has garnered a great deal of sensation. I met her in 1997, and across thirty years I have had many conversations about her. Many people have something to say about her. Every few years, an article is published that claims that she has been forgotten, with some new group of people claiming to remember her. I would argue that she has never been forgotten. The people who loved her, her friends, the people who knew her, many people in Sri Lanka have carried memories of her. It is the same with Anil, although because her writings were aimed at a general public, she is remembered less particularly, as she was less embedded within a field with modern architecture’s pronounced points of reference.

SKC: What was it like meeting Minnette de Silva? And how did that encounter influence the way you have engaged with her work, ideas, and intellectual legacy?

AIS: While Minnette de Silva’s friends and neighbors called on her regularly, I may have been one of the last people who traveled a distance to visit her in Kandy, in November 1997. I was not trained as a historian at that time—I was a practicing architect—but miraculously, something told me to interview her, and write everything down. I believe I met a person who had a clarity that some people experience at the end of life. She was able to put many events from her life into context. And what a context! The details were extraordinary: what she worked through, what she participated in, what she achieved as part of her practice. But to your question: I do not see my connection to her as producing any special custodial responsibility, and certainly not authority over a narrative. It was a privilege to meet her and to have since met many of her family members, friends, and colleagues. My connections are hardly lifelong, like those they had with each other. That meeting in Kandy created a highly personal spark that forged the impetus for my research, but my knowledge about her work comes from thirty years of looking closely at the practices and intellectual life she cultivated, those cultivated by her peers, and the social, political, and art and architectural histories they illuminate. So I want to push against the idea that the personal connection is freighted, that to be part of the social sphere of a subject or the provenance of an object increases its value and one’s own value in relation. Instead, I want to argue in favor of intellectual labor. A scholarly intimacy—and not the implications of proximity—is what we need to value.

Dominic Sansoni, Minnette de Silva in front of the studio at St. George’s, Kandy, 1998. Courtesy of Helga de Silva Blow Perera. Photo by author, Helga’s Folly, Kandy, 2014.

SKC: That distinction feels important. It also seems to complicate inheritance, because inheritance is not only about proximity or genealogy, but about who takes responsibility for carrying something forward.

AIS: Yes! To me, that is the real question of inheritance. I had the privilege of having conversations with Saloni Mathur as she was writing A Fragile Inheritance: Radical Stakes in Contemporary Indian Art (2019), about receiving the work of Geeta Kapur.3 Those conversations taught me a lot about what it means to be the receiver of an inheritance, and to translate it. But inheritance is about something much more than genealogical connections, whether they are intellectual genealogies or bloodlines. An inheritance is a charge one takes up. We are at a moment where we all must take up our ecological inheritance. Historians absolutely must. If we do not do it, who is going to do it? Anil de Silva-Vigier and Minnette de Silva did it before us, and we might start by looking at what they did and learning from it. 

SKC: Do you feel like you have a responsibility to Minnette de Silva in that sense? How do you understand your inheritance that you received from her, and what does it mean for you to carry it forward?

AIS: I do feel a responsibility to a person I met, and to a person who, in certain ways, handed me a baton. I do think I owe her a debt. But I owe a lot of people debts, as do you, as do we all. That is personal. But that is not the reason to write a book, or the reason a book’s argument would be meaningful. This business of who you know is a form of misuse; it’s damaging. I want to be very careful about it, and to me that is also part of the caretaking, and part of honoring someone’s work. I have had the privilege of meeting the people who checked on her every day, cared for her at the end of her life, sat with her in the hospital. These are holders of intergenerational knowledge, and they are not going to write a book about her. Similarly, there are many children of craftspeople who know the craft their grandparents taught them but will not practice it. In their case, they may want a different kind of employment that gives them a great deal more social mobility, or the possibility of a different life. And yet, they are the inheritors. While others may need to be the respectful custodians of this inheritance, so it is not lost, it is important to recognize the various forms of historiographical caretaking at play.

SKC: Ecologies of the Past seems to name both a historical subject and a method. It offers a way of reading architecture, craft, monuments, villages, water systems, bodies, institutions, and historical knowledge as interdependent fields. How would you want readers to understand ecology as a method in your work? What does it allow you to do that categories such as heritage, landscape, craft, or environment might leave apart?

AIS: A very short answer is that ecology is not metaphorical. It is real. Ecology is the intertwining of all these things. In one summary concept, it explains how the things you named—from heritage ideas to actual objects—are interconnected. Conceptually, this book starts with constructing and naming an ecology: the ecology of all the people these two sisters knew, the environments they worked in, the geographies of their travels, the things they made, what they wrote, and the visual culture they produced. It is about a history of material environments. Ecologies of the Past is also a form of historiographical caretaking. Working on this book has been about asking why one image was more important than another, why one choice of word mattered more than another. For example, I do not love Minnette de Silva’s writing. I do not know how interested I am in writings about “civilization,” which is a term that both sisters used. And yet it is very important for us to understand what that word meant in the 1950s and 1960s, in the contexts they were working in, the stakes and meaning of that term for them, what they might have been trying to appropriate through this terminology, how the term might have traveled, the slippages of the term. That, to me, is a way of building evidence: of a material ecology of environments and built forms, and also an intellectual, social, cultural, and conceptual ecology. These ecologies are our record.

SKC: Édouard Glissant’s notion of opacity offers a way to think about relation without full exposure.4 How does this shape your approach to intergenerational knowledge that is guarded, embodied, caste-bound, or intimate, especially when writing histories committed to care, preservation, and critique?

AIS: Glissant has helped illuminate a problem of colonialism through the concept of opacity, but with regard to craftspeople, enclosed caste communities are not only a problem of the colony or postcolony—they predate and also sit aside these “periods,” if we want to think of the histories in those terms. As much as I value his work, I do not know if Glissant’s thinking is necessarily the most appropriate framework here. I had the privilege of visiting a few craft communities, and I met craftspeople whose relatives had worked with Minnette de Silva a generation earlier, and with Ananda Coomaraswamy and Ethel Coomaraswamy a generation earlier than that. These are communities whose work may be dying out, and not for the first time. Minnette de Silva and Ananda Coomaraswamy each noted it in their own time; William Morris—whom they both read—foregrounded this problem. Scholars at the University of Peradeniya are working to preserve hereditary crafts in the region, and there are many communities open to sharing their knowledge, who are themselves preserving and codifying knowledge through the creation of curricula. But there are also communities that are not open to sharing their knowledge, for all the reasons we might understand; they are literally protecting their inheritance through opacity. 

SKC: So how do you understand the concept of opacity in relation to Minnette de Silva’s work?

AIS: Minnette de Silva pulled ecologies of the past—the crafts and the habitats in which they were embedded—into in her architectural work, and did so in a way that was very sensitive to something that we now understand, through Glissant, as opacity. She and her sister worked to preserve knowledge as far as it could be made universally available—for example, through writing the histories of monumental ecologies, or through adapting visual motifs found in hereditary crafts to modern architecture. They may also have been trying to protect actual people, directly employing craftspeople, for instance. One of the things that struck me in visiting some of these villages was that some are still not accessible by vehicle. In that sense, the opacity of the villages suggests they were not a site of resource extraction. Perhaps that is something we need to learn from. When the Nehrus came from India to visit the de Silvas in Ceylon during the years of the independence struggle, they were brought to meet craftspeople in the villages. These craftspeople were considered symbols of the emergent nation by leaders in the freedom struggle in two countries. The opacity of craft villages enables them to act as a cipher. The craftsperson is highly symbolic. Yet craft communities experience real precarity. They are suspended in a liminal position. Any aggrandizing of their symbolic value is negated by the diminishing of their political-economic value. So I do not want to valorize their opacity. I recognize it, and I think it is important, but I do not think we should romanticize it.

SKC: That distinction feels crucial: opacity cannot only be treated as an ethical or theoretical principle. It also has to be understood through infrastructure, labor, extraction, and the uneven conditions under which some communities become symbolically valued while remaining materially constrained.

AIS: Yes. We have to be conscious of the situation that many craftspeople find themselves in. Across South Asia, craftspeople have been held in a kind of gilded cage, and perhaps starved within it. Within our current context of neoliberal cultural appropriation, many craft communities have been able to claim agency and take control of their craft production, design, and aesthetic innovation. But that also has to do with global trade, which has been harmful in other ways. So it’s thorny. It is not as simple as saying, “Let us save everyone’s history.” I think we need to be honest about the systems we work within, the privileges we occupy, and the forms of exploitation we are also entangled in. I have experienced poverty in my life and in the parts of the world where I do my research. But I had never seen anything quite like the backbreaking labor and economic precarity of craftspeople, who may produce one fine product per year, with every fiber and breath, during all their waking hours. So, yes, we can honor opacity, but we also have to ask what that means in relation to labor, poverty, ecology, and extraction—what we should protect and what we should expose, when it is both none of our business and also very much our responsibility. This requires collective force.

SKC: I want to return to the question of feminist intellectual labor. Your book foregrounds the de Silva sisters and their sororal collaboration as a lifelong intellectual partnership, while also situating them within a broader feminist history: their mother Agnes Nell de Silva’s organizing with women laborers, Anil de Silva-Vigier's all-woman expedition to China, Minnette de Silva's architectural practice, and your own long process of reconstructing these layered inheritances. How do you think this sororal collaboration changes the way we understand architectural history and intellectual labor, and the institutions that helped shape them? 

AIS: Over some decades, there has been a push, in certain discourses, to write histories of women architects. Not necessarily questioning capitalist, nationalist, or other power frameworks—just putting women next to men in the story. Alternatively, there have been feminist labor discourses—for example, on wages for housework or family abolition—which have found their way into architectural discourse. I would call my project feminist in its methodology and even its subjects, more than in its objects. Although it is about two women, it is not about gender issues or these women’s life narratives. There are limits to what we can learn from cataloging every building that Minnette de Silva built, or the writings, however interesting, of Anil de Silva-Vigier. What I am attempting is a meditation on the value of a certain type of work: not only the produced work, but how they centered what I have come to call “ecologies of the past.” 

Table of Contents in Marg 3, no. 1 (1949).

SKC: Following from that, how does their collaboration help us rethink feminist practice in architecture?

AIS: Understanding their experiments as feminist practice lies in understanding collaborative practice. These were two hardworking people whose individual practices included mutual consultation and some collaboration, sometimes formally. They maintained a loving, lifelong conversation. My instinct to narrate this from the orientation of collaborative practice stems from the accident of meeting Minnette de Silva soon after her sister died. I encountered not just her loss of a sister, the familial loss, but her loss of a work partner—the person on the other side, the seedbed for the intellectual forays, who provided moral and scholarly support. At the time, I did not have the language to articulate that feeling of longing and loss attached to the creativity and utility of work, but I knew there was something that went beyond losing a sibling. To me, it is important to speak of intellectual labor and collaborative labor. Centering intellectual labor in architectural histories is perhaps even more urgent than the task of writing biographies of women, or upending our understandings of architectural labor. To center collaboration changes how we write architectural histories. It eliminates individual genius as the locus of innovation. Also, in Ecologies of the Past, I am trying to write an intellectual history of something that was aspired to, of agentive work. What did these women want to do? What did they desire? Those questions lie at the root of feminist histories. The narrative would be different if the protagonists had been men, yet the fact that they are women occupying the structural limits of their historical contexts matters. Minnette de Silva had an architect’s practice, just as Anil de Silva-Vigier had an art historian’s. I find it important that they engaged in the intellectual pursuits they chose, problems that interested them. That agentive and aspirational labor may make for a feminist history, but it also teaches us how we—the collective bearers of history—develop the sensitivity to hold and interpret histories that have only slowly come into view. 

Notes
1

Gottfried Semper, Style in the Technical and Tectonic Arts; or, Practical Aesthetics, trans. Harry Francis Mallgrave and Michael Robinson (Los Angeles: Getty Research Institute, 2004).

2

Nico Slate, The Art of Freedom: Kamaladevi Chattopadhyay and the Making of Modern India (University of Pittsburgh Press, 2025).

3

Saloni Mathur, A Fragile Inheritance: Radical Stakes in Contemporary Art (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2019).

4

Édouard Glissant, Poetics of Relation, trans. Betsy Wing (Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 1997).

‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌