Record - Kuukuwa O. Manful - Feeling for Remnants

Feeling for Remnants

Kuukuwa O. Manful

Arc_record_KM_05
Close up of a building permit file, Accra, 2021. Photo: Charles Lawson.
Record
November, 2026

The first time a student of history encounters a large and well-ordered archive can be intoxicating. There are the neat stacks of documents, detailed catalogs, efficient and helpful staff, precise, regimented, and sometimes stifling procedures for material retrieval and return which are exciting on their own. And then on top of that, there are mysterious fellow travelers probing their own historical enigmas which come together to foster a sense of unknowable and boundless possibility.

For many historians, these heady feelings will be the sum total of their emotive engagement with the physical space of “the archive.” However, for others, that same experience will also evoke feelings of yearning, loss, and rage alongside notions of absence, silence, omission, suppression, and destruction. 

Such were my feelings the first times I encountered repositories such as the UK National Archives (Kew), the British Library Archives and Manuscripts, and the University of Oxford’s Bodleian Archives & Manuscripts after starting my Accra Archive project, which digitized a collection of endangered architectural archives in Ghana.1 I could not help but contrast the dimly lit rooms and neglected piles of documents my team tackled in Accra with the large and bright document rooms in Oxford and London. 

Furthermore, the very fact of my being in these spaces was a privilege not available to numerous other researchers from Ghana and other nations of the world formerly colonized by the British Empire. The majority of archives and historical repositories pertaining to our countries are held in the Western nations which colonized ours, and accessing them is expensive, difficult, and out of reach for most researchers. In February 2026, the cost to get a single page scanned from the UK National Archives, for example, was around £8.40, representing about 4 percent of the average monthly salary for most university-employed researchers in Ghana who often have to self-fund their research projects.

Nonetheless, within the distance between the affective and geographic registers—of seeming abundance and apparent scarcity, of former metropole and former colony, of anticipatory excitement and hampered enthusiasm—lie opportunities to ask and answer historical research questions in unique and revealing ways. In particular, researchers who cannot expect to find all they seek in regimented institutional and national repositories need to approach archives, historical sources, and writing histories differently. As Christina Sharpe, Ann Stoler, Gil Hochberg, and others have noted with regards to writing about Black, colonial, and Palestinian histories, institutional archives and official records have limits: of coverage, of scope, of interest, and most crucially, of imagination.2 

The dearth and destruction of historical sources pertaining to African (architectural) histories, particularly on the African continent, is an oft-remarked problem. In the spirit of Kamau Brathwaite’s The Arrivants: A New World Trilogy (1973), and many others before and since who have proposed paths towards uncovering and recovering lost and deliberately suppressed (hi)stories, moving beyond the sole reliance on formal, conventional sources, to consulting those that are most frequently overlooked in studying history, such as children, is one path to making something torn and new out of fragmented African architectural records.3

Left: Unknown draftsman, architectural drawing, 1908. Digitized by Accra Archive in 2020. Right: Mr. Tackie (draftsman), architectural drawing, 1945. Digitized by Accra Archive in 2022.

Of Lost, Fragmented, and Destroyed Records 

In the late nineteenth century, John Mensah Sarbah, the Gold Coast–based nationalist, lawyer, and scholar of Akan law and customs, documented one case of destruction of historical records in the Gold Coast (now Ghana). When he chanced upon some men who had been given a stack of important, irreplaceable documents (which included copies of policies and treaties) to use as fuel to cook their lunch, he managed to rescue a small part of the material by parting with “threepence.” However, when he returned to retrieve the rest, he discovered that:

The remaining contents of the box were shortly afterwards pitched into the sea, it was said, by order of an [sic] high official. The archives of the Colony have been mostly destroyed. History is sometimes trouble-some; historical facts are often embarrassing in West Africa, and nothing so facilitates a spirited, indefinite policy as-a clean foolscap sheet of paper.4 

Sarbah was in prime position to fully understand what it meant for such legal documents and policy papers to be lost to Africans. He was a founder of the Aborigines’ Rights Protection Society, which successfully opposed many colonial policies and helped lay the foundations of the political independence of Ghana many decades later. He spent most of his career leading challenges to British colonial laws and policies in the Gold Coast.

Among the reasons for Sarbah’s effectiveness in arguing legal cases and bringing successful petitions to the British crown was his extensive knowledge of historical and contemporaneous Akan customary law, treaties agreed upon by the coastal rulers of the region and successive European occupiers, as well as past court cases which would serve to establish precedent for future cases. Africans in the Gold Coast were able to hold onto much more of their land than those in other colonies (such as in the settler colonies of Southern Africa) as a result of differently established land tenure systems.5 In no small way, these systems were strengthened by the ability of elites to argue their cases backed by the documentary evidence of treaties, court records, letters, and reports. Thus, more than a loss of some unwanted papers, the destruction of colonial documents by the British officials was an act of removing pesky evidence of land ownership, concessions, and legal judgements. It was an attempt to strip away a peoples’ power to represent themselves in ways legible to their colonizers.

Front page of Building Permit, 1928. Digitized by Accra Archive in 2020.

The destruction of archival records in African countries has not always been clearly or unarguably motivated by malice and a desire to avoid exposing embarrassing facts. Occasionally, it has occurred due to fear of state oppression and political targeting. Godwin Alaoma Onyegbula wrote about how as a Biafran administrator he destroyed papers in his possession out of fear of how the Nigerian government might use them:

Ikpa and I occupied ourselves going through the documents in our possession, to ensure that anything incriminating, which could be used against our people, was destroyed. Indeed, it was a painful task, reliving the experience of Biafra, and dumping into the toilet-bin, documents which stirred emotion. This we had to do, for in spite of Yusufu's warm-heartedness, we could not predict what the Nigerian authorities would do with us.6 

As Samuel Fury Childs Daly noted, this sort of destruction of archival material—to protect people from the furious power of oppressive states—was common at the time, and many records of the Biafra war from the Biafran perspective were destroyed, by Biafrans. Daly asserts that “Those who study the period after independence must look well beyond state archives, as there is often no grain to follow.”7  

“Something Torn and New”: Recovering Hidden Histories

In the third and final verse of the third and final part of The Arrivants: A New World Trilogy, Kamau Brathwaite captures the sense of making anew what was burned and broken, set to a rhythmic drumbeat and refrain of “bambalula bambulai”: 

…
hearing
waiting

watching
in the Lent-

en morning
hurts for-

gotten, hearts
no longer bound

to black and bitter
ashes in the ground

now waking
making

making
with their

rhythms some-
thing torn

and new8 

Ngũgĩ wa Thiong’o used the last lines of Brathwaite’s poem as the first part of the title his book about the “decolonization of modernity.” Something Torn and New: An African Renaissance (2009) explores the vicious effects of capitalism, slavery, and colonization and various modes of resistance by Africans on the continent and in diasporas.9 Using the concept of “dismemberment,” wa Thiong’o asserts that Africans were forcibly separated from their land. This “dismemberment,” far from being only physical was also emotional, epistemological, and mental—an attempt to destroy memories, and following that, histories. 

Although the colonial project of memory erasure and dismemberment has been frighteningly effective, people have still kept memories and accounts alive in various ways, such as the “peasants” in present-day Kenya who kept language traditions alive and living.10 In present-day Ghana, the women of Sirigu have kept alive wall-rendering and associated story-recording traditions going to this day. We may speak of others: the bronze crafters in Benin City in present-day Nigeria, the kente weavers in Agotime (present-day Ghana), the Zellige masters of Morocco, and many more. And although many of these traditions are constantly endangered by modern technologies, political pressures, and societal change, there are still people keeping these histories through craft and design. 

Despite these bright spots, there is still much that is obscured, silenced, or seemingly lost to the ravages of time, conflict, or neglect. Researchers attempting to access such (hi)stories must adopt creative methods, which at first glance may come across as counter-intuitive, because sometimes the keepers of historical knowledge and memories come in the most of unexpected packages. This can include the voices of the living rather than the long-dead, the never-built rather than edifices and ruins, and children rather than the elderly.

Research with African Adolescents

The challenges of conducting research where archival sources are few and far between, or inaccessible due to barriers of distance, cost, and credentials, are myriad, but so are the opportunities for truly creative, imaginative work. The attempts to suppress and dismember African historical sources have been going on just as long as the resistance to these attempts. For those working in contexts where official repositories silence as much or even more than they reveal, the path through is to find ways to make something new out of what has been torn. Children, for instance, can be engaged in research beyond questions of youth and of being young. They too are knowledge holders concerning their societies and the worlds they encounter.11  

This was powerfully illustrated to me in the course of field research in 2019, where the adolescent students at a secondary school in the Volta Region of Ghana had kept memories alive which their elders had long forgotten. Through school lore, passed on from one year group to another, as well as songs and chants circulated among classes and houses, these teenagers were able to show and tell me things that the older alumni, as well as teaching and non-teaching staff did not know or remember. For example, the students led me to the barely visible foundations of some of the oldest buildings that were constructed on the school campus, pointed out some of the oldest forget-me-not (frangipani) trees, and recounted stories of past academic successes of year groups when members of those year groups barely remembered them. 

None of the adults I spoke to in the course of my research—including community elders who were alive and involved in its construction—knew where the first-ever building that was constructed on the campus of their secondary school was originally sited because it had been demolished decades ago. And yet the students were able to show me exactly where the building was located, although all that was left were fragments of foundation walls covered up by soil and vegetation. Keeping and transmitting that specific memory of the origins of their school was very important to them. The transmission of stories from one cohort of students to the next, to remind them of the “sacrifices” made for the school and instill a sense of responsibility for the welfare of the school in them, can be understood as school myth-making.

This keeping and transmitting of memories by children is not rare or unique to that school in that region of Ghana. Across the African continent, and in many other places where children still play in groups, memories are kept alive through songs, rhymes, and games. Although the children may sometimes not know which specific (hi)stories they are sustaining or even why, the stories remain available for any who ask.

 

Notes
1

Endangered Archives Programme: Building Early Accra: Preserving Historical Building Permits in Ghana; UCLA Modern Endangered Archives Program: Digitizing Archives of Architecture in Ghana; Accra Archive, ➝.

2

Gil Z. Hochberg, Becoming Palestine: Toward an Archival Imagination of the Future (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2021); Christina Sharpe, In the Wake: On Blackness and Being (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2016); Ann Laura Stoler, Along the Archival Grain: Epistemic Anxieties and Colonial Common Sense (Princeton University Press, 2009).

3

Edward (Kamau) Brathwaite, The Arrivants: A New World Trilogy (Oxford University Press, 1973).

4

John Mensah Sarbah, Writings of John Mensah Sarbah (Bristol: Thoemmes Press, 2004), xi.

5

Unlike the nomadic and semi-nomadic nations in parts of Southern Africa whose lifestyles and relationship with the land involved leaving parts of their settlements unoccupied for periods of time, coastal nations in Western Africa tended to be more settled or sedentary. Thus, colonists were less able to claim land was unoccupied in Western Africa in the ways that they (falsely) did in Southern Africa. Moreover, many coastal nations in Western Africa such as the Akan nations have established rules and norms around receiving visitors to their land with clear demarcations in the areas strangers could stay, periodic ceremonies that reaffirmed host-visitor roles, contracts, and the like. See Kwame Arhin, West African Traders in Ghana in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Century (London: Longman, 1979); and Deborah Pellow, Landlords and Lodgers: Socio-Spatial Organization in an Accra Community (University of Chicago Press, 2008) for discussions of Zongo communities and “stranger quarters.”

6

Godwin Alaoma Onyegbula, The Memoirs of the Nigerian-Biafran Bureaucrat: An Account of Life in Biafra and Within Nigeria (Spectrum Books, 2005), 193, cited by Samuel Fury Childs Daly, “Research Note: Archival Research in Africa,” African Affairs 116, no. 463 (2017): 311–20.

7

Daly, “Research Note.”

8

Brathwaite, The Arrivants, 269–70.

9

Ngũgĩ wa Thiongʼo, Something Torn and New: An African Renaissance (New York: BasicCivitas Books, 2009).

10

Ngũgĩ wa Thiongʼo, Something Torn and New.

11

Kuukuwa Manful, “Research with African Adolescents: Critical Epistemologies and Methodological Considerations,” African Affairs 121, no. 484 (2022): 467–85.

‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌