November 20, 2026

Epistemic Disobedience and Earthy Cosmism in Ukraine: A Conversation

Olya Zikrata and Adrian Ivakhiv

Nikita Kadan, Protection of Plants, 2022. Courtesy of the artist.

This conversation took place at the SHIFT Centre for Social Transformation, Concordia University, Montreal, in April 2026. The conversation accompanied the exhibition “Ukraine: No Filter,” organized in collaboration with Club Ukrainien de Montréal and cocurated by Olha Holovko and Olya Zikrata.1 The exhibition focused on material and photographic evidence, visual storytelling, and wartime audio recordings that trace the targeting of Ukrainian life, inviting audiences to witness the impact of war and engage with the realities faced by those living through it. The event coincided with a talk by Adrian Ivakhiv on the anthology he edited, Terra Invicta: Ukrainian Wartime Reimaginings for a Habitable Earth, published last year by McGill-Queen’s University Press.2

***

Olya Zikrata (OZ): You begin the Terra Invicta anthology with a freeze-frame from a video recorded the day after the full-scale Russian invasion of Ukraine began. It features Ukrainian president Zelensky and his associates addressing fellow Ukrainians with the words “We are here” (Ми тут / my tut), which you read both as a statement of courage, speaking to the decision of many Ukrainians to stay and defend the country, and as a commitment to place, land, a piece of earth—an act of staying and holding ground. In other texts, you rework this relation to place, to tut, into the notion of tuteishyi, “one who is from here,” one whose being is shaped by situated belonging—an “earthbound” identity, in Bruno Latour’s terms. This identity helps us understand collective becoming, especially in defense of the zemlia, the earth.3

More broadly, you situate the Russo-Ukrainian War within the politico-ecological history of the last few centuries, rethinking Russian imperialism through the lens of “multipolar neo-imperialisms” and the politics of climate disaster operating along the expansion-extraction nexus. This framing helps show that what has happened to Ukrainians is not unique; it resonates with the experiences and struggles of other people who have faced imperial and settler-colonial wars and climate disasters, and who were left with no choice but to find ways to survive what had been forced on them. How do you think this reformulation of Russia’s war in Ukraine can contribute to how it is globally being understood and responded to, especially within activist cultures?

Adrian Ivakhiv (AI): An underlying message of Terra Invicta, which means “Unconquered Earth,” is that the earth is unconquered and will remain so, and that humans can choose to align themselves with it or not. Viewed from this perspective, war is always environmental. This isn’t only the case with the Russo-Ukrainian War; however, I outline a series of ways in which this war is especially environmental.4 Environments are targeted and placed at risk; the aggressor, Russia, is a fossil-fuel state hellbent on maintaining and strengthening its status, and in the face of the looming decline in the value of fossil fuels, it must do something to strengthen its imperial grip; ethnocide, which is a clearly articulated Russian goal, is always ecocidal; relations with environments are a source of identity for Ukrainians; and so on.

The bigger picture is that this war is continuous with a much longer history, one that can itself be read as a “long war”: between extractive industrialism, as represented by its colonial, imperial, and capitalist vanguards, and communities that have lived more “lightly” on the earth and more tightly in connection with their environments, and that are therefore “in the way” of the former. Until we take sides in that war and come to the defense of its victims, we enable its aggressors.

You ask about global political and activist cultures. It’s understandable, to some extent, that activists in the West and even more in the Global South might retain some sympathy toward the Soviet legacy, despite its Stalinist atrocities. But this of course ignores not only the authoritarian reality of the entire Soviet experience, but the nakedly capitalist and now imperialist nature of Russia today. Moreover, the Putinist regime trumpets a radically conservative discourse that, whether it believes in it or not, it sells abroad, fueling and funding “culture wars” and propping up far-right proxies, from the US to Brazil to almost every country in Europe. Western leftists have been especially slow to recognize that the Cold War is over, that the anticipated triumph of the liberal capitalist West—Francis Fukuyama’s “end of history”—never came to pass, and that we are instead well into an era of multipolar neo-imperialisms, which happens to coincide with a digitally hyper-powered informational world disorder. The neo-imperial powers compete for resources and for military dominance alongside techno-economic powers—oligarchs and corporate fiefdoms—that collaborate when convenient, and otherwise compete behind each other’s backs in a race for technological dominance.

Carving out an “earthbound” politics for a planetary future is a challenge for the rest of us, and it starts with the recognition that we are all poised to suffer—we are all precarious—in the face of climate change and the massive destabilizations that will accompany it. So we have a lesson to learn from those who are already losing their land and fighting to defend it. Ukrainians are in this sense not just victims, but also exemplary resisters.

OZ: I agree with you. There is so much to learn from the Ukrainian resistance, yet it remains recast as a geopolitical abstraction rather than taken as a lived, situated practice of collective survival. In this context, I find Kateryna Botanova’s essay in Terra Invicta to be pivotal, as it responds to broader knowledge politics around Ukraine. Botanova writes that Ukrainians face “a two-fold epistemic battle”—which is now arguably three-fold, needing to respond to how they are seen by Russia and the West, and now also by a Global South that chooses “to ignore Russian atrocities in favour of playing an imaginary counter-balance to the Global West.”5 Ukrainians are left in a liminal condition, constantly required to respond to shifting and emerging colonialities; they can only respond through what Botanova calls “epistemic disobedience.”

AI: This epistemic disobedience responds to cognitive imperialism. It’s nothing new that Ukrainians find themselves amidst and between imperialisms. I’m reminded of the old villager in Yuri Illienko’s film The White Bird Marked with Black (1971) who is constantly stumbling into the ticking alarm clocks he has set up for each of his region’s sequential territorial occupiers—respectively showing Romanian time, Polish time, German time, Russian time—in order to be prepared for whoever may come next. Ukrainians have arguably developed the skill of adapting to changing imperial pressures almost as well as anyone.

But then there is also epistemic creativity, which emerges from the free assessment of one’s own condition, of one’s immanent relations, and of the hopes for how those relations can unfold without the imposition of those cognitive or material imperialisms. That is where decoloniality becomes real—it’s still an open project. It’s fueling the resistance to the Russian onslaught, but it can also be found in a certain artistic and philosophical tradition of what we might call Ukrainian “earthy cosmism”—not the space-age fabulation of the better-known Russian cosmists, but a more worldly and grounded, pantheistically inspired thinking and expression one finds in Ukrainian philosophers like Hryhorii Skovoroda, and in poets and artists from Taras Shevchenko and Lesia Ukraïnka to Pavlo Tychyna and Bohdan Ihor Antonych, and from Oleksandr Dovzhenko to Fedir Tetianych, Alla Horska, and some of the artists featured in Terra Invicta. And then there is the long tradition of folk artists like Maria Prymachenko and Polina Raiko (whose village was flooded by the Nova Kakhovka Dam explosion, as discussed in Svitlana Biedarieva’s chapter).

I see this epistemic creativity in the work of the artists featured in the book, such as Nikita Kadan, Kateryna Aliinyk, Katya Buchatska, and Kateryna Lysovenko. Some of these works come from an exhibition called “Heart of Earth” (Sertse zemli), held at Ukraine’s largest museum-gallery complex, the Mystetskyi Arsenal in Kyiv, in the midst of the war in late 2022 and early 2023. The works I chose to include are those that resonated with the volume’s emphasis not only on the eco-cultural trauma of war, but on the paradoxical weightiness and gravity of the earth, the way the earth and land are both generative—they feed us, and will continue to do so for generations—and are a repository of memory, history (including the traumas of the Holodomor), and struggle.6

There is no escaping history, only a reframing of it so that it enables the continuity of life. This is a theme that’s deeply ingrained in Ukrainian culture, philosophy, art, literature—from Skovoroda to Olha Kobylianska and Vasyl Stefanyk, to Dovzhenko’s Earth and the works of Serhii Paradzhanov and Yuri Illienko in the 1960s and ’70s (such as the latter’s A Well for the Thirsty [1965]), until today. For Ukrainians it is perhaps obvious that the resistance to Russian aggression is in large part about the land, but for Westerners it’s not clear at all, so this became the driving theme of the book.

OZ: This understanding can be seen as countering other readings of Ukrainian identity (whether ethnic or national, as you write elsewhere).7 Yet it also serves as an opening to rethink Ukrainian positionality along earthbound Latourian lines—in order to really grasp what is at stake in this war, what is being defended and why—and also to rethink what kinds of identities may emerge as we work to confront what Isabelle Stengers calls “the coming barbarism.”8 In this sense, Ukrainians’ earthbound resistance against the genocidal-ecocidal force of Russian neo-imperialism is inspirational.  

Ukrainian artists have been doing important work to document and publicly share the lived experience of Russia’s war by engaging in what Asia Bazdyrieva and Svitlana Matviyenko call the “labor of witnessing.”9 This is the intensive, embodied work of registering wartime reality so as to transform what is lived into a political demand for justice. You return to this at the end of the preface to the book, recalling the circumstances under which the volume was written, with some authors displaced by the war and others remaining under constant threat of Russian strikes.

Yet you manage to find kernels of hope in the art featured throughout the book. For instance, you build the closing of your introductory chapter around the work of Katya Buchatska, who speaks of bomb-cratered fields that “look like a sieve” (from Buchatska’s video This World Is Recording), in which she imagines trees growing from the seeds that are planted “so that we have something to lose.”10 In some ways, this thinking from the fields of genocidal-ecocidal devastation reminds me of what Black scholars like Ayana Omilade Flewellen do when they perform embodied witnessing. Flewellen literally submerged themself in ocean waters to excavate history from the wrecks of ships that carried their enslaved ancestors across the Atlantic.11 The sites of horrific crimes become active epistemic grounds.

It is the question of futurity—the capacity to have a future, even when that capacity has been violently interrupted—that Terra Invicta keeps circling in different registers. It begins with the subtitle, Ukrainian Wartime Reimaginings for a Habitable Earth, which opens onto a series of creative interrogations of what kind of Ukraine remains (in)habitable and what kinds of futures are still possible under conditions of ongoing war, occupation, and planetary crisis. This is the kind of work many of the contributors perform throughout the volume.

AI: This line from Buchatska was very poignant and eloquent: “We plant a garden so that we have something to lose.” Wartime is a time of survival, not a time for dreaming different futures, and yet artists tend to do the latter because of the ways they reframe the present to bring out its paradoxes, resonances, and surreal reference points.

The entire volume is, as you say, infused with the wartime experience of Ukrainians, who are looking beyond the war toward what has been and what can be otherwise. This theme of envisioning the world otherwise has been a prominent current within the environmental humanities, particularly in conversation with decolonialism, feminism, and Indigenous and Black studies that are dedicated to rethinking the ways we live on this earth. It is a kind of “Ukraino-futurism” that we seek—a term that Svitlana Matviyenko, Asia Bazdyrieva, and I develop further in Bernd Herzogenrath’s wonderful anthology Spectral Futures.12 Theorizing these relationships to formulate a viable way forward for a globally coordinated eco-social movement will take a lot more work. But I see Ukraine and the current war as offering insights as well as lessons for that larger project, which, whatever else it may be, will need to be a project of global solidarities.

This discussion has been edited for length and clarity.

Notes
1

See →.

2

For an open-access PDF of the book, see →.

3

Bruno Latour, Facing Gaia: Eight Lectures on the New Climatic Regime, trans. Catherine Porter (Polity, 2017), 248ff.

4

Adrian Ivakhiv, “How War Is Environmental: The Ukrainian Case,” Terrestri(e)alism, Substack, April 24, 2026 →.

5

Kateryna Botanova, “Decolonial Thinking and Artistic Practice in Ukraine After February 2022,” in Terra Invicta, ed. Adrian Ivakhiv (McGill-Queen’s University Press, 2025), 58.

6

The Holodomor was a “man-made famine that convulsed the Soviet republic of Ukraine from 1932 to 1933. It was part of a broader Soviet famine (1931–34) that also caused mass starvation in the grain-growing regions of Soviet Russia and Kazakhstan.” Anne Applebaum, “Holodomor,” in Encyclopedia Britannica, published October 11, 2026 →.

7

Adrian Ivakhiv, “Becoming Tuteishyi: Ukraine in the New Global Climatic Regime,” East/West: Journal of Ukrainian Studies 11, no. 1 (2024) →.

8

Isabelle Stengers, In Catastrophic Times: Resisting the Coming Barbarism, trans. Andrew Goffey (Open Humanities Press, 2015).

9

Asia Bazdyrieva and Svitlana Matviyenko et al., “Mental Geology of Nuclear Threat” and “The Labor of Witnessing,” Transmediale panels, August 25, 2023 →.

10

See →.

11

Ayana Omilade Flewellen, “Submerged in the Wake: Keynote,” posted May 5, 2026, by 4th Space Concordia University, YouTube →.

12

Asia Bazdyrieva, Adrian Ivakhiv, and Svitlana Matviyenko, “Specters of Solar Futurity: Yellow-Black-Yellow,” in Spectral Futures: Fabulations of Worlds to Come, ed. Bernd Herzogenrath (Bloomsbury Academic, 2026).

‌
‌
‌
‌
‌